Louise Daniel on February 26th, 2010

Minutes of the Planning Committee Meeting of 9th February 2010 held at 7.00pm. in the High Hurstwood Village Hall, High Hurstwood.


Present: Cllrs. Sheard (Chairman), Blandford, Chalmers, Crowe, Dopson, Harding and Rose.  Also in attendance Cllr. Downing, WDC Cllr. Buck and Miss B Macklen, Clerk to Buxted Parish Council
Public:2. Dr David Wright and Fiona Thorpe of Buxted Surgery.
1. Apologies: Apologies were received and accepted from Cllr. Warner
2. Minutes: The minutes of the meeting of 26th January 2010 were approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman.
3. Declaration of Members Interests in respect of items on this agenda
Cllr. Chalmers declared a personal interest in any matter relating to the Ionides Trust land by virtue of being a Member of the Trust.

Cllr. Crowe declared a personal interest in item 4.5 on the agenda WD/2010/0174/F Lower Totease Cottage, Framfield Road by virtue of knowing a neighbour to the site and having had previous correspondence with the applicant regarding the adjacent Lower Totease Farm.

4. Planning Applications
Application No. WD/2010/0051/F & WD/2010/0052/LB

Location: Chillies East, Chillies Lane, High Hurstwood

Description: Conversion of existing main loft area, including the reconstruction of the north dormer and the addition of two small south facing dormers.

Applicant: Mr & Mrs D Mills

Agent: NPR Associates

Recommend Approval – subject to consultation with Conservation and Design Officer.

Application No. WD/2010/0083/F

Location: Brackenwood, Five Ash Down

Description: Proposed ground floor extension and alteration and new roof to form new first floor accommodation

Applicant: Mr W Cole

Agent: 3-D Architecture

No objection

Application No. WD/2010/0084/F

Location: 28 Littlewood Lane, Buxted

Description: Proposed extension to rear of existing double garage

Applicant: Mr & Mrs D Tibbs

Agent: Real Design

Recommend Approval

Application No. WD/2010/0132/FR

Location: Lower Sleeches Farm, Fowley Lane, High Hurstwood

Description: Conversion of agricultural building to form two semi-detached dwellings

Applicant: Mr H Cox

Agent: Mr B James

Recommend Refusal – the Parish Council would reiterate previous comments that the proposal is contrary to the policies of PPS7, the Wealden Local Plan and the Brighton and Hove Structure Plan in respect of its siting within the AONB outside of any development boundary, in an area where strict control and restraint is exercised over the provision of new residential development.  The agent has provided a further viability assessment of the existing and proposed uses and concludes that the conversion of the two buildings is the

most profitable use of the land as a use for holiday lets is considered to be marginal at best.  The Parish Council would not only question where this information has been drawn as it is aware of many successful holiday let businesses in the area, but would also wish to point out that although a conversion to residential use would be more profitable for the applicant, a justification on the basis of profit cannot surely be taken into consideration when the concept of conversion for this purpose is clearly outside of any development plan policies. Moreover the building deemed for conversion is not of any sufficient architectural or historical merit to require saving by conversion. The permission for conversion to holiday lets was made predominantly on the basis of benefit to the locality by encouraging tourism. If it is now deemed by the applicant that this is not sufficiently profitable to justify the expense of conversion then no works should progress.

Application No. WD/2010/0174/F

Location: Lower Totease Cottage, Framfield Road, Buxted

Description: Two storey extension

Applicant: Mr N Rideout

Agent: Mike Hill – Architectural Services

No objection

5. Any other matters properly notified
Dr Wright and Fiona Thorpe kindly attended the meeting following a request by the committee as minuted at the meeting of 26th January 2010.  All in attendance discussed the proposals for a new surgery on the Ionides land with all parties agreeing that it is very important that this project has a joined approached with the Ionides Trust, Ryhurst and HOBI group working together on the site as a whole to ensure that a new surgery and hall have the best possible design and siting in order to form a new heart to the village on what is a landmark site. Members of the Parish Council were fully cognoscente of the need to consider the working aspects of the surgery build and restricted budgets that had to be worked with – these were key aspects that will have to be considered in relation to the development of the community hall – but not at the expense of good design that has a sense of place that is appropriate for this landmark site. These were aspects that Ryhurst, their architects and the PCT had been clear on from the outset.

To this end, Dr Wright was asked to make contact with the PCT and Ryhurst to ask if they would be willing to meet with the HOBI group’s architect, Simon Barker, so that ideas for the site and its cohesion can be discussed. Furthermore, in order to keep Dr. Wright as informed as possible, he was also invited to attend the next HOBI group meeting, taking place on Monday 22nd February in the Reading Room at 7pm when a draft site masterplan will be discussed.

6. AnnouncementsNone this meeting.
The meeting closed at 7.50p.m.
Louise Daniel on February 17th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Clerk: Miss R Macklen

PO Box 202, Heathfield

East Sussex TN21 1BN

Phone/Fax: 01435 812757

Email: clerk@buxtedparish.org.uk

Website: www.buxtedparish.org.uk

16th February 2010

The Chairman and Members of the Planning Committee

The Chairman and Vice Chairman of the Council, copy: other Members of the Council

NOTICE OF MEETING

The Planning Applications below are to be considered by members of the Planning Committee on 23rd February 2010 at 7.30p.m. in the Reading Room, Buxted

At the discretion of the Chairman, members of the public may speak or ask questions immediately before the consideration of each planning application on the agenda.

1. Apologies for Absence

2. Declaration of Members personal and prejudicial Interests in respect of items on this agenda

3. The minutes of the Planning Committee held on 9th February 2010 be approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman.
4 Planning Applications

4.1. Application No. WD/2009/2589/FR

Location: The Old Orchard, St Mary’s Garth, Church Road, Buxted

Description: Change of use to B1. Construction of porch over pre-existing concrete path alongside one side and front of pre-existing shed. Installation of wood-burning stove and double insulated flue.

Applicant: Dr E Davies

Agent: Dr E Davies

Sent: 16.02.10

4.2. Application No. WD/2010/0012/F

Location: Streele Wood Farm, Framfield (Not in Parish, but consulted by WDC as near neighbours)

Description: Retrospective application for log cabin with flue for use when working in wood 14 days a year.  Extension to existing barn

Applicant: Mr A Miklaucich

Agent: Mr A Miklaucich

Sent: 09.02.10

4.3. Application No. WD/2010/0264/F

Location: Lilac Cottage, Chillies Lane, High Hurstwood

Description: Remodelling of kitchen, first floor extension and utility/porch extension to gable end

Applicant: Dr I Sly

Agent: Boswell Associates (Architecture) Ltd

Sent: 09.02.10

5. Any other matters properly notified

· Areas of Councillor responsibility

6. Announcements – a) Chairman of the Committee; b) Clerk to the Council

Beccy Macklen

Clerk to the Council

Copy to ESCC Cllr A G Reid, WDC Cllrs. N A D Buck & K Ogden


Louise Daniel on February 17th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Minutes of the Planning Committee Meeting of 26th January 2010 held at 7.55 pm. in the Reading Room, Buxted.

Present: Cllrs. Sheard (Chairman), Crowe and Warner. Also in attendance Miss B Macklen, Clerk to Buxted Parish Council

Public: None

1. Apologies: Apologies were received and accepted from Cllrs. Blandford, Chalmers, Dopson, Harding, Rose and WDC Cllr. Buck.

Apologies were made by Cllr Sheard for late start of meeting due to delays caused by an accident on the A272.

2. Minutes: The minutes of the meeting of 12th January 2010 were approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman.

3. Declaration of Members Interests in respect of items on this agenda:

Cllr. Warner declared a personal interest in respect of any discussion involving the new surgery and Ionides Trust site by virtue of being a Parish Council representative on the Ionides Trust.

4. Planning Applications

Application No. WD/2009/2571/F

Location: Brownheath House, Pound Green, Buxted

Description: Extension to existing garage to provide two additional parking spaces – replacing existing poor quality flat roof with shallow pitched roof to improve both visual and weather proofing in the building.

Applicant: Dr J Pereira

Agent: Mr D Nicholson

No objection – however the Parish Council would comment that its regrets the chosen roof materials but understands the rational that a metal roof keeps the ridge low and would be unable to convert to further accommodation in the future.  The Parish Council therefore requests that the roof colouring is sensitive to the location and would suggest that either dark green or dark red would be suitable.

Application No. WD/2010/0020/F

Location: Newnham Park Farm, Poundgate, Crowborough

Description: Alterations and additions

Applicant: Mrs L Lloyd

Agent: Mike Hill – Architectural Services

No objection

5. Any other matters properly notified

Members briefly discussed the proposals for the new surgery on the Ionides Trust site and thought that now that the scheme is progressing, it might be a good idea for the doctors to be invited to the next meeting of the Parish Council to share with Councillors any thoughts that they may have on the current designs of the building in order to ensure that communication between all parties is maintained throughout the whole process and before the designs go to public consutlation.  The clerk is to write to the doctors.

6. Announcements

None at this meeting.

The meeting closed at 8.30p.m.

Signed:                                                                         Committee Chairman

Date:


Louise Daniel on February 17th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Minutes of the meeting of the Council held in the Reading Room, Buxted on Tuesday 19th January 2010 at 7.30 p.m.

Present: Cllrs. Crowe (Chairman), Blandford, Daniel, Dopson, Downing, Harding, Rose, Seddon, Sheard, Warner and Wilkes (8.05pm).

Also present: Miss R Macklen - Clerk.

Public : 1: Mrs Ings

01/01/10 APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Apologies received and accepted from Cllrs Chalmers, Treacher, WDC Cllr. Buck and ESCC Cllr. Reid.

02/01/10 DECLARATION OF MEMBERS INTERESTS.

Cllrs. Daniel and Warner declared personal interests in any matters concerning the Basil Ionides Memorial site by being members of the Ionides Memorial Trust appointed by the Council.

Cllrs. Rose and Downing declared a prejudicial interest in any matter relating Land west of Church Road by being the owner of the property adjoining the land.

03/01/10 MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING

The minutes of the meeting held on 8th December 2009 were signed by the Chairman as a correct record of the meeting.

04/01/10 ESCC REPORT

Nothing to report in the absence of ESCC Cllr. Reid

05/01/10 PARISH COUNCIL NEWSLETTER

Firstly Members expressed how pleased they all were that Cllr. Daniel has decided to stay in England and thus with the parish council.

It was agreed that the next issue of the Community Voice newsletter should be published either just before or at the time of the Annual Assembly in May in order that it can include the Chairman’s yearly report. Ideas for this edition were to include an article based on the recently published WDC road safety review; and recycling (do’s and donts e.g. mixed bottles in the banks) and the expansion of kerbside recycling across Wealden which is scheduled to happen during 2010.

06/01/10 OUTSTANDING MATTERS

Item 1 Parish Plan Objectives:

PP/ Action 1. Youth Council:

Cllr. Warner reported that the youth council had met for its cross generational technology session, but unfortunately only one member of the public attended and the school’s servers were being worked on and thus the technology was not working correctly.  Subsequently, it has become apparent that the adult education service now visit Buxted Court to give help and advice on technology and it has been requested that the youth council maybe follow up this visit to continue to help residents if they are experiencing difficulties or if there is anything they did not understand.

The youth council are also currently applying for grants from the Big Lottery’s Funding for Young People to support members attending a higher level first aid course and for further play equipment at the Ionides site.

Youth council members would be attending the New Hall Workshop as invited either on Thursday or Saturday.

PP/ Action 3. Public Footpaths:

Cllr. Blandford reported that she had spoken to Russell Lines, the general manager at Buxted Park regarding previous concerns raised about footpaths through the park.  She was advised that Buxted Park is working with Natural England on the preservation of the Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) and will produce a management plan which will also be displayed on boards within the park to explain its aims and objectives. As part of the management plan endorsed by Natural England is also the leasing out of land to local farm holders to keep sheep in the park.  The recent problem of sheep worrying could have an impact on this which would result in the park losing the sheep which could then affect any grant awarded by Natural England – let alone traumatising the sheep if not actually injuring or killing them.

There have also been problems with visitors parking on areas not allocated and then being abusive to staff who ask them to move. This is unfortunate and could impact on the long term public use of the site.

Referring specifically to the footpath issue, Buxted Park recognises that many footpaths which run through the site and have been walked for many years are passive’ and not ESCC registered footpaths.  However, as part of the new management plan, it was advised that some of these ‘passive’ footpaths may have to have restricted access in the future.

Mr Lines did stress however, that he is happy to keep communication open.  Parish Council Members agreed that Cllr. Blandford should continue to be the councils contact with the park to ensure the park forges a closer relationship with the community now that communication has reopened.

Members also discussed the recently received footpaths survey from ESCC which was clearly based on a very comprehensive assessment of all footpaths in the parish, but unfortunately did not provide a detailed report.  The clerk was asked to contact ESCC and request further detailed information regarding local footpaths.

Following a short discussion and agreement by the Cllr. Blandford as the parish’s Tree Warden, it was agreed to have ‘Trees’ as a separate item on the agenda listed under Outstanding Matters.

Item 2 Road Safety:

The Chairman advised that due to the recent weather conditions, the Speed Watch team have been unable to be out and about as much as they had hoped.  Now that the snow has gone, the teams aim to be back out as normal.

The recently circulated School Travel Plan newsletter was discussed, and it was again noted that Buxted Primary School cannot implement a full plan due to the unsuitable and unsafe road conditions leading up to the school from the village. Regrets that County Highways still did not recognise this were reiterated.

Members discussed the recently published Wealden District Council Road Safety Review, which is a report compiled by WDC Members and officers as part of the Community Scrutiny Committee work programme.  The report is enormously detailed, giving many statistics and valuable pieces of information that are relevant to all parishes and towns in the county.  Members specifically mentioned the reference to Section 106 contributions from developments towards road safety improvements and how this opportunity was missed by WDC for safety improvement on the A26 through the Temple Grove and Grampian planning applications.  It was agreed that the Pass Plus scheme should be promoted and it is good to see both WDC and ESCC supporting the idea to encourage young people to take part.  A further encouragement should be its incentives such as the reduction in insurance costs.  The report also highlighted the need for street and house names and numbers to be clear and visible in order to assist emergency services when attending incidents.

The report had also been forwarded to Rob Storey as the Speed Watch coordinator for Buxted who raised concerns that through a poll of parish councils, it had become apparent that speed cameras were considered the best form of speed control through villages.  This came as somewhat of a surprise to Rob, who is more than aware that speed cameras only serve to slow traffic as they pass the camera.  It was agreed that averaging speed cameras either end of the village are the most effective at slowing traffic on a far more permanent basis and should be encouraged for the future in the County as well as the Parish.

Members were interested to find out what WDC will decide to do with the information in the report following its consideration and hope that it is used to try and influence ESCC Highways current policies.

It was agreed that an article based on the report should be included within the next Community Voice newsletter and that Cllr. Daniel would aim to include a short article highlighting the report in the next Buxted Messenger and High Hurstwood newsletter.

Item 3 Grampian site FAD:

The clerk reported that she had attended a meeting between ESCC, the developers of the site and local residents at which issues of concern were discussed.  It is hoped that these issues have now been partially resolved.

Cllr. Dopson commented that since the erection of the new bus stops on the A26, it has been reported that the public consider that they are too close to the road and therefore feel safer if they walk into the village and catch the bus from there. This did not surprise Councillors.

Item 4 Land west of Church Road: Nothing to report.

Item 5 New Parish Hall & health centre:

Cllr. Warner reported that a meeting between the Ionides Trust, Ryhurst, the PCT and Simon Barker had taken place the previous evening at which the revised plans for the surgery in line with PCT costings were considered.  The surgery had been reduced in size since the original plans were viewed and this reduction had been agreed by the doctors; and that comments fed back previously by the Trust had been taken on board.  However, concerns were now raised at the industrial looking nature of the building, so Ryhurst were asked to soften and ruralise the building.  Concern was also raised at the building materials, specifically the metal roof to which Ryhurst explained that they considered that a 45° pitch might appear intrusive if tiled, so a metal roof was being suggested to allow a low lying roof.  The number of car parking spaces has been reduced to 35 ostensibly to meet WDC requirements and the two storey element of the building is now set down the slope of the site to reduce impact – however it has been moved closer to the road at the top of the site which the Trust requested be amended in order to leave a green space on the corner of Framfield Road/A272. Cllr. Warner also mentioned that Simon Barker, the chosen architect for the hall project, was extremely helpful at the meeting.

The next stage is for Ryhurst to finalise the design before a pubic meeting is organised to view the design in February.  The Ionides Trust have ask Ryhurst for examples of materials and other buildings of similar style and design by which to consider the impact of the building further.

Cllr. Crowe thanked Cllr. Warner for her update and urged the Ionides Trust to stand firm on the principles of what was originally agreed and not to let Ryhurst pressure the Trust into accepting a building that the community will regret. From the outset of discussions Ryhurst, the PCT and doctors were well aware that any building needed to respect the setting at the Heart of Buxted. It was also noted that the 35 car parking spaces would only serve the surgery – this was also not what was agreed with Ryhurst at the beginning of the project who stipulated that they would provide the car parking, access and services for both the surgery and new hall.

Everyone was reminded that the New Hall Workshops were taking place on Thursday for invited organisations and on Saturday between 10.00am and 1.00pm for all members of the community to attend. They are a first opportunity for the community to have dialogue with Simon Barker as the community architect and start to engage with the Heart of Buxted Initiative.

Item 6 Wealden LDF: Nothing to report.

Item 7 Emergency Plan: Nothing to report.  Nearly had to use during recent bad weather, but snow fortunately subsided.

Item 8 Property Issues:

The clerk reported that the leaky roof above the Reading Room kitchen is being fixed.

Item 9 Parish Council Website:

Cllr. Daniel report that work continues on the new website with the structure now in place with many items having been uploaded.  The design and visuals now need to be looked at and decided upon.  It was therefore agreed that Cllr. Daniel and Cllr. Blandford would look into this before giving a demonstration of the new site to Cllrs at a forthcoming meeting.

07/01/10 CORRESPONDENCE

P1, P3, P5, P6, P7 – Parish Residents: requests for grit bins in various locations – This matter was given careful consideration with Members discussing in detail how East Sussex County Council have put the onus on parish and town councils to pay for the installation and filling costs of new grit bins without any notification or consultation.

Members’ initial concerns were the number of grit bins the parish council may end up having to supply. If the seven current requests were agreed, it would then be in a very difficult position to say no to any further requests. At a cost of £273 per bin, with a further £70 for each fill, this could have serious implications on the parish council budget and ultimately parishioner precept rates. The effectiveness of the bins is also of particular concern given that across the Parish and the wider County a number of grit bins were emptied recently, but the grit was used on private driveways and not the highway or pathways as it is intended.

Members were very concerned that the parish council precept budget has not, and should not have to cater for a service which is the responsibility of another authority. Any further stretch on parish council funds needs to be seriously considered given that parishioners already pay for this service and other winter roads maintenance through their Council Tax to East Sussex County Council. Other parish councils faced with a number of requests for new grit bins also are of the same opinion.

Unfortunately, East Sussex County Councillor Reid was not in attendance as it was hoped that he would have been in the position to report back on the first of the County Council’s meetings to review its Winter Roads Maintenance Policy which took place last week.

It was therefore resolved that whilst the results of the East Sussex County Council audit of its Winter Roads Maintenance Policy are awaited, the parish council would not invest in any further grit bins for the parish at this time. Instead the parish council, in line with other Parish and Town councils, would encourage open dialogue with the County Council as to how they plan to ensure adequate future winter roads maintenance. If this then requires parish and town councils to take more responsibility then the costs of this will need to be agreed with the community. We will keep the community informed of discussions with County prior to decisions being made.

Members of the council noted that they too have all been affected by the recent bad weather and are fully appreciative of the problems associated with snow and ice on the minor roads (and now potholes) – let alone the problems on the more major thoroughfares and pavements in the towns as well as the villages.

It was felt that perhaps in preparation for potential future bad weather the parish council should suggest that where a number of residents are particularly affected, then perhaps there could be some clubbing together to obtain small stocks of salt and grit (if available) and perhaps also contingency working parties. This worked reasonably well in some parts of the Parish and in other areas – with members of the community working together to common good.

The clerk was also asked to investigate a missing grit bin from Gordon Road, which appears to have been relocated within a BT owned site.

P4 Mrs Loveday: Can grit bins be paid out of private donations? – The clerk advised that the legalities of this matter are being investigated by SALC as this question has arisen in many parishes and towns across the district.  The clerk would update Members and Mrs Loveday as soon as an answer is received.

P2 Local Works Campaign: Request for support regarding the Empowering Local Councils and Sustainable Communities Act Amendment Bill – Some Members reported that they had individually written to Charles Hendry MP and the clerk has written on behalf of the parish council.

P8 Victim Support: Request for grant – Members agreed that Victim Support carries out some invaluable work and resolved to award a grant of £100 as in 2008/09.

P24 NWCTP: Invitation to Meeting on 4th February – As the parish of Buxted is soon to be introduced to the door to door bus scheme Members felt it appropriate that the parish council should now be represented at the meetings.  Cllr. Downing and Cllr. Harding volunteered to attend and to find out exactly when the service will be extended to the parish.

08/01/10 COMMITTEE MEETINGS

None since previous meeting.

09/01/10 FINANCE

Cllr. Wilkes reviewed the income and expenditure in December 2009 advising of all the necessary payments in January 2010 noting the relatively small amount of payments for the current month.  It was resolved that cheques 753 to 757 be drawn on the current account totalling £3459.33 including voucher charges be authorised for payment.  The month’s bank statements were verified against the bank reconciliations.

10/01/10 OTHER MEETINGS

Cllr. Sheard advised that he had attended a Parish Liaison of Ashdown Forest meeting and was pleased to note that more people attend each time.  Cycling across the forest was discussed with a scheme potentially being set up which would allow a recognised cycling club to ride in dedicated areas.  There is not quite a commitment to the scheme as yet, but the door is still open.

Deer accidents were reported with an estimated 1000 deer needing to be culled to keep the population down – however local land owners are not willing to allow culling on their land.  The overriding message was that if you travel at over 40mph at night across the forest, you are at serious risk if you hit a deer.

Cllr. Downing reported that she had attended a meeting of the Buxted Action Group at which the following matters were discussed:

· The news that the Wealdlink (NWCTP) scheme is coming to the parish was welcomed

· People in High Hurstwood are still interested in allotments and are thinking of applying for a grant under the title of the land being a community garden.

· Parking at Maypole Cottages is still a problem, but ESCC are considering converting the roadside verge into further parking for residents

· The garages and Maypole Cottages are also an issue with local residents wanting more parking – WDC would have to agree

· The group would ideally also like ESCC to provide a lay by in which the Southern Water tank which visits the cottages to empty the septic tank could use rather than blocking the road.

· It was reported that WDC are going to provide Buxted Court with further disabled and non disabled parking

· The AGM is either the 15th or 22nd March depending on the availability of High Hurstwood Village Hall.  Cllr. Warner was asked to attend on behalf of the parish council.

11/01/10 MEMBERS QUESTIONS

1. Cllr. Rose raised a concern with regards to his appointment to the Wealden District Association of Local Councils (WDALC) group.  He has been attending these meetings for some time alongside Cllr. Chalmers, but is unsure of exactly why the group exists and what its aims and objectives are.  It seems to meet regularly and discuss matters relating to the parish councils present, but the group does not appear to influence other bodies and there seems to be no decision making process by which change is brought about.

He requested that another Cllr. attend in his place to advise if he is incorrect in his assumptions.  Members however were minded to agree that Cllr. Rose’s interpretation is correct and instead the clerk should contact neighbouring parish councils to establish if they still send representatives to the meetings.

Subsequent to the parish council meeting, the clerk has spoken to Cllr. William King of Maresfield Parish Council who also sits on the WDALC management committee and who advised that he could understand the frustrations of our councillor but urged the parish council to remain involved in the group as it continues to maintain a joint parish council approach on issues of concerns for parish councils and from time to time WDALC does influence some big decisions.

2. The clerk advised that Councillors concerns had been relayed to WDC in the recent survey they sent. The clerk also advised that WDC continues to push forwards with electronic planning consultations with parish councils.  It is hoped that during the initial trial phase, all problems and difficulties experienced by parish councils would be identified and mitigated against before the scheme is rolled out to all parishes by the end of the year.

12/01/10 ANNOUNCEMENTS

The clerk advised that Hadlow Down Parish Council is in the process of organising an evening event at which Trevor Leggo from SALC would be invited to explain the process of gaining Quality Parish Council status.  Buxted parish councillors are invited to attend.  Members agreed that this is good idea.

Hadlow Down Parish Council have also asked if councillors from both councils would like to have a joint approach with regards to attending meetings of outside bodies e.g. WDALC.  Considering the discussions above, the clerk would respond that although considered a good idea, at present, Buxted Parish Council may not have a willing representative to attend WDALC meetings but if this changes or there are other meetings then perhaps such a joint attendance could occur.

The meeting closed at 9.27p.m.
Signed:                                                    Chairman

Date:

Louise Daniel on February 7th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Clerk: Miss R Macklen

PO Box 202, Heathfield

East Sussex TN21 1BN

Phone/Fax: 01435 812757

Email: clerk@buxtedparish.org.uk

Website: www.buxtedparish.org.uk

2nd February 2010

The Chairman and Members of the Planning Committee

The Chairman and Vice Chairman of the Council, copy: other Members of the Council

NOTICE OF MEETING

The Planning Applications below are to be considered by members of the Planning Committee on 9th February 2010 at 7.00p.m. in High Hurstwood Village Hall, High Hurstwood

At the discretion of the Chairman, members of the public may speak or ask questions immediately before the consideration of each planning application on the agenda.

1. Apologies for Absence

2. Declaration of Members personal and prejudicial Interests in respect of items on this agenda

3. The minutes of the Planning Committee held on 26th January 2010 be approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman.
4 Planning Applications

4.1. Application No. WD/2010/0051/F & WD/2010/0052/LB

Location: Chillies East, Chillies Lane, High Hurstwood

Description: Conversion of existing main loft area, including the reconstruction of the north dormer and the addition of two small south facing dormers.

Applicant: Mr & Mrs D Mills

Agent: NPR Associates

Sent: 26.01.10

4.2. Application No. WD/2010/0083/F

Location: Brackenwood, Five Ash Down

Description: Proposed ground floor extension and alteration and new roof to form new first floor accommodation

Applicant: Mr W Cole

Agent: 3-D Architecture

Sent: 26.01.10

4.3. Application No. WD/2010/0084/F

Location: 28 Littlewood Lane, Buxted

Description: Proposed extension to rear of existing double garage

Applicant: Mr & Mrs D Tibbs

Agent: Real Design

Sent: 26.01.10

4.4. Application No. WD/2010/0132/FR

Location: Lower Sleeches Farm, Fowley Lane, High Hurstwood

Description: Conversion of agricultural building to form two semi-detached dwellings

Applicant: Mr H Cox

Agent: Mr B James

Sent: 02.02.10

4.5. Application No. WD/2010/0174/F

Location: Lower Totease Cottage, Framfield Road, Buxted

Description: Two storey extension

Applicant: Mr N Rideout

Agent: Mike Hill – Architectural Services

Sent: 02.02.10

5. Any other matters properly notified

· Areas of Councillor responsibility

6. Announcements – a) Chairman of the Committee; b) Clerk to the Council

Beccy Macklen

Clerk to the Council

Copy to ESCC Cllr A G Reid, WDC Cllrs. N A D Buck & K Ogden


Louise Daniel on February 7th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Clerk: Miss R Macklen

PO Box 202, Heathfield

East Sussex, TN21 1BN

Phone/Fax: 01435 812757

Email: clerk@buxtedparish.org.uk

Website: www.buxtedparish.org.uk

2nd February 2010

The Chairman and Members of the Council,

NOTICE OF MEETING

You are summons to attend the meeting of Buxted Parish Council to be held on Tuesday 9th February 2010 at 7.30p.m. at High Hurstwood Village Hall, High Hurstwood

The public have a right and are welcome to attend and at the discretion of the Chairman, members of the public may ask questions prior to the commencement of the business proper. Any Police update will be given at this point.

AGENDA

1 Apologies for absence

2 Declarations of members’ interests in respect of items on this agenda

3 Minutes of the 19th January 2010 meeting (enclosed) to be confirmed and signed

4 ESCC report

5 Parish Council Newsletter

6 Outstanding matters – For Information Only unless otherwise stated:

Ø Parish Plan Actions:

Action 1. Youth Council

Action 3. Public Footpaths

Ø Trees

· 2010 Subscription to International Tree Foundation

Ø Road Safety

Ø Grampian site FAD

Ø Land west of Church Road

Ø New Parish hall & health centre

Ø Wealden Local Development Framework

Ø Emergency Plan

Ø Property issues

Ø Parish Council Website

7 Correspondence – as tabled at the meeting

8 Committee meetings

9 Finance: (i) to approve invoices for payment – to be tabled ii) to receive bank reconciliation

10 Reports on other meetings attended by members

11 Members questions

12 Announcements – a) Chairman of the Council; b) Clerk to the Council

Beccy Macklen

Clerk to the Council

Copy to ESCC Cllr A G Reid, WDC Cllrs. N A D Buck & K Ogden


Louise Daniel on January 30th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Minutes of the Planning Committee Meeting of 12th January 2010 held at 7.00pm. in the Reading Room, Buxted.

Present: Cllrs. Sheard (Chairman), Crowe, Harding, and Warner. Also in attendance Cllr. L Daniel

Public:

1 - Emma Logan, applicant for WD/2009/2486/F

1. Apologies: Apologies were received and accepted from Cllrs. Blandford, Chalmers, Dopson and Rose.  Apologies also received from WDC Cllr. Buck and Miss B Macklen (clerk).

2. Minutes: The minutes of the meeting of 8th December 2009 were approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman.

3. Declaration of Members Interests in respect of items on this agenda

Cllr. Crowe declared a personal interest in respect of planning application WD/2009/2651/F Ringles Cross Cottage, Ringles Cross by virtue of having an employee who is a friend of the applicant and the tenant of the application property being the child of the employee.

4. Planning Applications

Application No. WD/2009/2455/F

Location: The Millstones, Five Ash Down

Description: Side and rear extension to first floor bedrooms and single storey rear extension.  New single garage and store

Applicant: Mr S Butterfield

Agent: Mr J Butterfield

Objection – recommend refusal. The extension as proposed, which is a 40% increase in footprint, would have a negative and unacceptable impact on the neighbouring property, New Lodge, by virtue of its size and massing which would result in the extended property being imposing and visually over dominant causing a loss privacy and more significantly a loss of light to the north side of the New Lodge.

Whilst the Parish Council does not object to the erection of a garage, the siting as proposed is considered inappropriate due it being situated so close to the frontage of the property boundary. Other dwellings along this stretch of road have the benefit of garages, but all are situated further back into the front gardens to maintain an acceptable building line and to ensure access to and from the driveways is not obscured (please see attached photographs). This stretch of the A26 is difficult to access and good visibility is paramount, The Parish Council would therefore request that the garage be re-sited aligning it with others nearby. Although not a planning consideration, it has also been brought to the attention of the Parish Council that a covenant exists which may prevent the erection of any structure so close to the frontage of the site. Finally it is also understood that there used to be a grass verge between the pavement and the fence line of Millstones which has been recently subsumed into the curtilage of the property with the erection of criss-cross fencing (as shown in the photographs) – whether this means the public highway has been taken into the curtilage ought to be checked by ESCC.

Application No. WD/2009/2492/F

Location: Pinewood, Station Road, Buxted

Description: Demolition of redundant garage workshop and construction of one dwelling house.

Applicant: Ms R Miller

Agent: WAS Chartered Architects

Objection – Recommend Refusal. Although the ridge height of the proposed dwelling has been reduced, the Parish Council would reiterate previous objections to a dwelling of this size on this site. A four bedroom property would not meet the stated need for smaller homes in the village and would instead create an over development of the site causing an overlooking of the adjacent properties. The size, massing, scale proportions and design of the dwelling are not considered compatible with the size of the site and character of its surroundings. Given that the proposal is for a four bedroom chalet bungalow, there has been inadequate consideration given to both the space around the dwelling and the number of allocated parking places. Other than the two spaces provided, any further parking would have to be on Station Road (A272) which would be obstructive on such a busy road through the centre of the village and would also inevitably impact on the visibility splays of others using the access track and nearby track to the parish allotments.

The Parish Council would also be concerned at where construction materials/skips etc would be kept during construction. If WDC were minded to approve this application then a condition should be included requiring details to be submitted and approved which would ensure good practice measures for site working in order to mitigate potential impacts from construction/construction vehicles/materials on surrounding properties, the access track and the adjacent A272 Station Road given the site is so close to the main road through the village.

Water run off from the site and a suitable soak away system is also a concern due to the widely recognised flooding issues in the area.

As stated previously, the Parish Council do not object to a smaller dwelling on this site, but the proposals as submitted are still considered too large and over dominant for this plot.

Application No. WD/2009/2627/F

Location: Subiaco, Ringles Cross, Uckfield

Description: Rooms in roof and raising of roof pitch

Applicant: Mrs J Crowhurst

Agent: Larkins & Pollington

Objection. Subiaco is a small bungalow in a small site with very little scope for increasing the property by extending the footprint. However, raising the ridge height and creating a dormer window which would result in a 50% increase in living space as proposed it is however not considered appropriate due to the lay of the land. The windows as shown would result in an unfortunate overlooking of the neighbouring properties to the rear resulting in a loss of privacy. If however, the Planning Authority are minded to approve the application, it is requested that the rear windows be obscured glazed to ensure no loss of privacy.

Application No. WD/2009/2651/F

Location: Ringles Cross Cottage, Ringles Cross, Uckfield

Description: Proposed change of use of existing retail storage & commercial accommodation to residential accommodation. Demolition of existing external store & erection of single storey entrance porch.

Applicant: Mr Hartfield

Agent: 3-D Architecture

No objection. However, the Parish Council would draw the officer’s attention to the implementation of a previous application WD/2009/0843/F which required the applicant to provide detailed proposals for the planning of a native hedge or shrubs for screening the fence along the road frontages of the site before the installation of the fence. The Parish Council therefore requests confirmation that these landscaping proposals have been submitted in accordance with condition 2 as the fence is in situ.

5. Any other matters properly notified

With approval of the Chairman, the following item was considered as Urgent Business in order to comply with WDC consultation deadlines having got lost in its original delivery from WDC.

Application No. WD/2009/2486/F

Location: Eden Cottage, Framfield Road, Buxted

Description: Two storey side extension and associated alterations to domestic dwelling house.

Applicant: Mr S Logan

Agent: John Tadman BD & S Associates

No objection – recommend approval

6. Announcements

The Committee discussed the recently submitted planning application WD/2009/2515/MAJ for the erection of an agricultural building for free range hens at Five Chimneys Farm, Hadlow Down.  Although the site is situated within the parish of Hadlow Down, it lies adjoining the parish boundary and is therefore of some concern to parish residents who back onto the site. Members discussed the history of the site and how an application for a further 16,000 free range chickens, taking the total number at the site to 35,000 would seriously impact on the nature of the AONB and the surrounding ancient woodland.  The Clerk was asked to respond to the planning application on behalf of Buxted Parish Council.

Subsequent to the meeting, it was agreed that the following response to the application be sent to WDC and a copy sent to Hadlow Down Parish Council and the professional surveyors representing the adjoining owners:

Given the application site is within a short distance from the Buxted parish boundary with Buxted residents backing onto it, the Parish Council felt is appropriate to comment on the proposal.

Although it is recognised that planning policies should support rural businesses, it is considered that a further free range poultry house in this location would have a serious and detrimental impact on the landscape of the sensitive nature of the AONB as well as a potential detrimental impact on neighbours.

The original poultry house which it is understood now houses 7,000 chickens is situated in a far more visually discreet area of the farm to the east of the applicants’ own home thus having less impact on the surrounding area.  In an application in 2006 for an additional house for 9000 chickens at the proposed new site, resulted in serious objections being raised by various parties including the High Weald AONB Unit and within WDC that this additional development on this new site would be detrimental to the AONB as well as being much more impactful on the countryside as well as potentially having a negative effect on neighbouring properties. That planning application was refused by WDC. However in 2008, against officer recommendation and with serious objections including from the High Weald AONB Unit, a further planning permission was granted for a second poultry house to contain 12,000 chickens which is situated in this far more visually intrusive area which the applicant bought and has taken into the curtilage of their land holding. This was surprising and rather disappointing given the previous refusal. To date, this has not been constructed and therefore the impact of this building cannot yet be measured.  To now be considering a further poultry house for 16,000 chickens on what is well recognised as a sensitive site cannot possibly be supported.

The impact of a further poultry shed in this location would have the effect of an industrial sized development which would directly impact on the neighbouring properties and traditional historic field boundaries and have a detrimental impact on the character and integrity of the High Weald landscape in direct conflict with policies put in place to protect the AONB.

Furthermore, the impact that 28,000 free range chickens on this site will have on the ‘range’ area around the poultry houses has not been assessed.  Releasing the chickens in such close vicinity of ancient woodland will undoubtedly have adverse effects.

The Parish Council would request if an assessment has been submitted to show how a development of this size and scale will affect the surrounding countryside and ancient woodland in the AONB?

In conclusion, Buxted Parish Council considers that the proposed application, if approved, would have a significantly detrimental affect on the AONB and ancient woodland surrounding the site, contrary to policies GD2, NE5, BE1 and DC3 of the NSLP and PPS7 and should be refused.

The meeting closed at 8.05p.m.

Signed:                                                                         Committee Chairman

Date:


Louise Daniel on January 21st, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Minutes of the meeting of the Council held in the Reading Room, Buxted on Tuesday 8th December 2009 at 7.30 p.m.

Present: Cllrs. Crowe (Chairman), Blandford, Downing, Harding, Rose, Seddon, Sheard, Warner and Wilkes (7.45pm).

Also present: Miss B Macklen Clerk to Parish Council.

Public : 2 – Mr Giles & Ms Fallon

01/12/09 APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Apologies received and accepted from Cllrs. Chalmers, Daniel, Dopson, Treacher, ESCC Cllr. Reid and WCD Cllr. Buck

02/12/09 DECLARATION OF MEMBERS INTERESTS.

Cllr. Warner declared a personal interest in any matters concerning the Basil Ionides Memorial Centre by being a member of the Ionides Memorial Trust appointed by the Council.

Cllr. Rose declared a prejudicial interest in any matter relating Land west of Church Road by being the owner of the property adjoining the land.

Cllr. Downing declared a prejudicial interest in any matter relating Land west of Church Road by virtue of living close to the site.

03/12/09 MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING

The minutes of the meeting held on 10th November 2009 be signed by the Chairman as a correct record of the meeting.

04/12/09 ESCC REPORT

Nothing to report in the absence of ESCC Cllr. Reid.

05/12/09 PARISH COUNCIL NEWLSETTER

The Chairman reported positive feedback following the issuing of the latest edition of the Community Voice newsletter (No.7). It was also reported that Cllr. Daniel will be resinding her retirement from the Parish Council as she has decided not to relocate to Holland. All Members were very pleased to hear this news.

06/12/09 OUTSTANDING MATTERS

Item 1 Parish Plan Objectives:

PP/ Action 1. Youth Council:

Cllr. Warner advised that the Youth Council will be meeting the following evening at Buxted School for the cross generational communication evening.  Unfortunately no one had registered a formal interest in attending at the time of the meeting, but it is hoped that some members of the community would attend the session.  Members thought that a lack of commitment may be due to the dark evenings, so a further session perhaps during the spring/summer is encouraged.  Cllr. Harding showed an interest in attending and the Chairman considered sending her partner if he is free.

PP/ Action 3. Public Footpaths:

Following the receipt of a telephone call and subsequent letter circulated to Members, the Clerk reported that concern has been raised with regards to Buxted Park and the gradual reduction in available walking space.  Historically, on the most part, the community has been able to enjoy the vast majority of the park however changes are being made which is having the effect of reducing the public open space.  Anglers are now utilising some areas in addition to the renting out of some areas of land for local smallholders to keep sheep.  Unfortunately, to add to the situation, there have been incidents of sheep worrying and mauling which have led to the smallholder being present on site with a gun (the Police are aware).

Members discussed that although the land has been widely utilised by the community over many numbers of years, the park is privately owned and the owners are well within their rights to restrict visitors to the public footpaths.  It is unfortunate, however, that past communication with the Parish Council and community seems to have deteriorated to little or no information being passed on.

Members considered it appropriate for the Parish Council to make contact with Buxted Park to enquire as to what further changes will be made. This will then allow the Clerk to be in a better position to advise members of the community when asked. It was agreed that Cllr. Blandford would informally contact the manager of Buxted Park and report back to the Clerk.

The Chairman advised that some time ago, the now retired chairman of the Footpath Committee had undertaken work with regards to footpaths within the park and had approached ESCC with regards to formally recognising further paths that were being created through historical precedence by those who walk in the grounds.  Unfortunately, this process is very lengthy and requires a substantial amount of evidence to support the formalisation of new paths.  It was therefore suggested, that if the community were minded, they could collectively collate and provide all evidence required so that a formal approach to ESCC could be made. Even with this work it had however to be recognised that it may not result in a successful formalising of paths that the community have been using.

Item 2 Road Safety:

It was reported that it is understood through a representative of the Heron’s Gyhll community that on the 15th December, a meeting will be taking place between ESCC officers and the Police which will discuss the recent fatalities at Heron’s Ghyll.  As the Parish Council has not been formally notified of the meeting or requested to provide any input, the Chairman has contacted Cllr. Reid to ask that this matter is not considered in isolation, but part of joined up thinking to include all interested parties to ensure the best outcome. The Chairman noted there had been some discussion in the local press on the issue of the A26 and speed limits.

Item 3 Grampian site FAD:

The Clerk is to attend a site meeting on 16th December with representatives from ESCC and ESCC Cllr. Reid in connection with ongoing issues relating to a neighbour of the site.  The Clerk is attending purely as an observer.

Item 4 Land west of Church Road:

It was reported that the farmhouse has now been sold.

Item 5 New Parish Hall & Health Centre:

Cllr.Warner advised that a meeting of the HOBI (Heart of Buxted Initiative) group together with the chosen architect had taken place the previous week at which the group discussed the submitted Community Grants Application to Wealden District Council which could award up to £15,000 to the project.  The group then went on to discuss proposals by the architect of how best to engage the community in the project.  It was agreed that the community’s input could best be obtained via two days of workshops with both the architect and his associate artist.  The workshops would be held at the Reading Room and would consist of a first day comprising of an invitation to existing organisations i.e. primary school children, Scouts, Art Group, W.I. to attend and take part in organised activities including the marking out of the proposed hall on site and the making of models and sharing of ideas.  The second session would be half a day on Saturday 16th January and would be open to all members of the community to attend and ask questions, to see the outputs from the invited groups and particularly the school, put forward their own ideas, make models, share any concerns and to ask general questions of the architect.

It is also hoped that from the public session, some further members of the community may come forward who wish to become part of the HOBI group.  Following the workshops it will also be necessary for the HOBI group to become a formal charity in order to be able to receive funds, make expenditures and be eligible to apply for grants.  A constitution has already been drawn up and circulated to all existing members of the HOBI group with two members already committing to the charity and taking on tasks required for the workshops.

The Chairman advised that costs associated with publicity and catering for the two public sessions were kindly being covered by the Ionides Trust through monies made from the recent Autumn Fayre.

Cllr. Warner reported that progress on the Health Centre is slow with the both Ryhurst and Ionides Trust solicitors working through points of the legal agreement.  The architect engaged by the HOBI group has had a viewing of the initial plans for the health centre.  From viewing these plans, the architect, with the approval of Ionides Trust members will approach ESCC and WDC to discuss how best the hall could be designed in order to ensure it leads the design on the site.

Item 6 South East Plan: Nothing to report.

Item 7 Wealden LDF: Nothing to report.

Item 8 Emergency Plan: Nothing to report.

Item 9 Property Issues:

Cllr. Downing raised three issues regarding the Reading Room:

1) The vacuum cleaner does not work efficiently – Agreed that Cllr. Crowe would donate a vacuum cleaner.  If not considered suitable by the caretaker a new vacuum cleaner will be purchased.

2) Guttering above door to under stage storage – Agreed the Clerk to organise repairs

3) Waste bin lid broken – Clerk advised a new bin has been ordered from WDC.

Item 11 Parish Council Website

Cllr. Blandford updated that work is ongoing on the new website with a new test homepage already available to view on the web.

07/12/09 CORRESPONDENCE

P1 ESCC: Third Local Transport Plan 2011-2026 – Clerk to contact ESCC Cllr. Reid to ascertain parish council involvement, as it was understood at a Buxted Action Group meeting that the intent was to engage to local community through the parish council asking what locally is required.

P2 Rural Services Network: Survey regarding public transport, affordable housing, primary schools, facilities for your people and support services for older people – Members collectively completed the questionnaire. Clerk to return to ESCC.

P3 Horticultural Society: Request for replacement tables – Clerk to write and advise that the Parish Council would not be replacing the old wooden tables at this time.

P4 Unlock Democracy: Request for Parish Councils to help campaign to ensure Sustainable Communities Act Amendment Bill is adopted by Parliament – Clerk to send standard template letter on behalf of Buxted Parish Council.  Other Members encouraged to respond individually.

P5 Samaritans: Request for grant – Resolved that a grant of £50.00 be awarded, as previously awarded in 2008/09.

08/12/09 COMMITTEE MEETINGS

None since previous meeting.

09/12/09 FINANCE

Councillor Wilkes reviewed the income and expenditure in November 2009 advising of all necessary payments in December. It was resolved that cheques 744 to 752 be drawn on the current account totalling £7043.20 including voucher charges be authorised for payment. The month’s banks statements were verified against the bank reconciliations.

10/12/09 OTHER MEETINGS

Cllr. Seddon reported that she had attended the Power of Well Being training at Uckfield Civic Centre but was surprised that there was a test at the end of the session.  Other Members who have also attended the training were surprised as they had not had a test.

11/12/09 MEMBERS QUESTIONS

Following a question from Cllr. Rose, the Clerk confirmed that a report had been received by EDF following the Reading Room wire testing which did include the storage area under the stage and which did not highlight any urgent works required.

12/12/09 ANNOUNCEMENTS

All at the meeting were invited  to share some mince pies and sherry courtesy of the Chairman.

The meeting closed at 8.35p.m.

Signed:                                                    Chairman

Date:

Louise Daniel on January 15th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Minutes of the Planning Committee Meeting of 8th December 2009 held at 7.00 pm. in the Reading Room, Buxted.

Present: Cllrs. Sheard (Chairman), Blandford (7.05pm), Crowe, Harding, Rose, and Warner (7.10pm). Also in attendance Cllr Downing and Miss B Macklen, Clerk to Buxted Parish Council

Public:

8.

Mr Sergent and Mr & Mrs Edgington addressed the committee in relation to agenda item 4.1 – WD/2009/2384/F Land adjacent Hazelhurst, Church Lane, Buxted.  They raised many concerns regarding the proposed dwelling which included (1) Relocation of the previously approved dwelling to a new position on the plot which will create a loss of privacy and overlooking across the garden area of 1 The Common; (2) Removal of trees which were conditioned to remain as part of the original planning permission; (3) The addition of a double garage to the front of the property; 4 the unsightly machinery at the plot has not been removed; and (4) Due to an existing business being run from the site, the lane is becoming impassable and there are grave concerns that building works will exacerbate this situation further with existing residents forced to pay for damage done by others.

Mr Giesler addressed the meeting in relation to agenda item 4.3 - WD/2009/2427/F Bartons, Chillies Lane, Crowborough advising that at the present time, the business is being tested for viability from his home, but if successful would be moved to more suitable premises such as an industrial estate.

Mr S Giles addressed the committee in relation to agenda item 4.4 – WD/2009/2461/F Brigadoon, Etchingwood, Buxted raising a number of concerns regarding the proposal which included (1) Overdevelopment of the plot; (2) Drainage and flooding issues (3) Loss of privacy; (4) Proposed dwelling is out of keeping with the surrounding area; and (5) The removal of the existing landscaping at the site.  He clarified his points in full adding that the proposed footprint of the replacement dwelling is 150% larger than that of the existing and also extends 9m to the front and 6m to the back of the existing building line of the lane.  Furthermore the dwelling sits sideways into the plot resulting in all main living areas overlooking that of the neighbouring property, Elm Cottage. All landscaping has been erased from the site which means that the new property will now overlook neighbours to the sides and rear and opposite – when previously the site was enclosed by a mature and rural garden. The roof height is also higher than that of the neighbouring property which seems bizarre as the proposed property is described as a single storey dwelling whereas the neighbouring property is two storey. The application forms advise that the dwelling will be attached to the mains sewer – but no such sewer exists as properties in this lane feed into septic tanks the tank at Brigadoon already posing issues without such a large house being built to use it. Flooding is also an issue, specifically water run off from the site into the neighbouring property due to site level changes. Finally, Mr Giles requested that the design of the dwelling is amended to mitigate overlooking into the neighbouring property, be scaled down, moved further back into the site onto the existing footprint and the ridge height of the roof be reduced, and that section drawings be requested showing adjacent properties and in addition to a full landscaping plan given that all existing landscaping has already been removed from site.

1. Apologies: Apologies were received and accepted from Cllrs. Chalmers, Dopson and WDC Cllr. Buck.

2. Minutes: The minutes of the meeting of 24th November 2009 were approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman following an amendment to the attendance list.

3. Declaration of Members Interests in respect of items on this agenda

Cllr. Rose declared a personal interest in respect of planning application WD/2009/2384/F Land adjacent Hazelhurst, Church Road, Buxted by virtue of knowing the applicant.

Cllr. Rose declared a personal interest in respect of planning application WD/2009/2402/F Totease House, Station Road, Buxted by virtue of knowing the applicant.

4. Planning Applications

Application No. WD/2009/2384/F

Location: Land adjacent Hazelhurst, Church Lane, Buxted

Description: Change of design to current approval under application APP/C1435/A/05/1181760 plus new double garage and garden building

Applicant: Mr M Lewis

Agent: Scandia-Hus Ltd

Object – Recommend Refusal. Although the principle of a dwelling on the site has already been established via an appeal decision, the proposed dwelling is strongly objected to by both the Parish Council and residents local to the site.  The proposed new dwelling is two storeys – this is considered to be visually intrusive within its setting compared to the previously approved chalet bungalow.

The Parish Council very much regrets the approval on appeal considering the impact of any dwelling on the private access road over which the property is reached.  The previously approved dwelling did not present a design of any architectural merit, but was of modest size and sat better within the site than the proposed large dwelling which does not confirm to the Wealden Design Guide principles.

As detailed in the appeal inspectors decision when granting planning permission for a chalet bungalow, he states:

“It is of modest size and design and would be situated between two other houses; subject to additional landscaping, it would have very little impact on the countryside and AONB.”

The new design is not in keeping with surrounding properties, is of considerable size and the proposed balconies would overlook and be intrusive to the neighbouring property. Furthermore, the existing landscaping at the site, conditioned to remain unless otherwise approved, has been removed, thus opening up the site further to the surrounding countryside and overlooking of adjacent properties.

The proposed two storey dwelling, as now submitted could not possibly be described as modest or in keeping with the AONB as it is considered to be out of character with its surroundings and an overdevelopment of the site.  The relocating and repositioning of the dwelling would be overbearing and result in an unacceptable overlooking of the neighbouring property, 1 The Common, having a detrimental impact on the amenities of this property and would be an incongruous design adjacent to the two existing chalet bungalows.

Although the applicant has advised that the large barn/garage building to the rear of the site is to be removed as part of any permission, it would be replaced in part by the addition of a large new garage to the front of the property and a further incongruous garden room to the rear, thus adding to the proliferation of buildings within this sensitive site.

It is therefore considered that this development would be contrary to policies GD2, BE1 and DC16 of the Wealden NSLP and policies GD2, EN6 and DC17 of the Adopted Wealden Local Plan.

It is noted that the existing permission for a chalet bungalow as detailed above has now expired, having been given permission by the appeal inspector on 12th October 2005.  The result of this – it is assumed – is that the chalet bungalow cannot now be built as the five year period in which development should begin has expired and no development has commenced on site.

The Parish Council would continue to argue that a new dwelling on this site is inappropriate – however given that a precedent may have been set by the appeal inspectorate, any further development should be in line with the inspectors report and should consist of a dwelling of modest size, proportion and design and be more in keeping with the previously approved chalet bungalow with much less fenestration at first floor level.

If minded in any way to approve the application, WDC are requested to ensure that all existing storage buildings; commercial vehicles; and the caravan are removed from the site.  The Parish Council would also request that as part of any development on site there is a requirement for the surface of Church Lane to be reinstated/improved by the applicant as it is currently almost impassable due to the heavy commercial vehicles still visiting the proposed development site.  Additional traffic movements created by construction vehicles will only serve to exacerbate this problem requiring current local residents to carry out further work to the privately owned lane to rectify the damage done by the owners of this site. Furthermore, given that the current owners have removed all existing landscaping from the site, this and any future application should include a detailed landscaping scheme to help ameliorate any further impact of the development on the surrounding area.  It is requested that the applicant must be responsible for both the landscaping and resurfacing/reinstating of the road surface if permission is deemed appropriate either now or into the future.

Application No. WD/2009/2402/F

Location: Totease House, Station Road, Buxted

Description: Erection of detached treble garage forming courtyard with existing residential buildings

Applicant: Mr & Mrs M Duncan

Agent: Downlands Design and Surveying

No objection

Application No. WD/2009/2427/FR

Location: Bartons, Chillies Lane, Crowborough

Description: Construction of addition to end of existing garage to provide pizza oven in association with pizza delivery business (retrospective application)

Applicant: Mr P Giesler

Agent: Mike Hill Architectural Services Ltd

No objection – however the Parish Council would urge the planning authority that if minded to approve, a temporary permission only is applied to ensure minimal requirement for the business to be located within this residential area if successfully established.

During consideration of the above item, the Chairman suspended Standing Orders to allow the applicant to clarify that the reasons for a retrospective application were that he approached WDC to request an extension to the existing garage, of which only part would be used for pizza making, and was advised that planning permission would be required for both the extension and change of use.

Application No. WD/2009/2461/F

Location: Brigadoon, Etchingwood, Buxted

Description: Demolition of existing dwelling and outbuildings and the erection of new private single storey dwelling house and associated garage.

Applicant: Mr D Whitting

Agent: Stephen Langer Associates Ltd

Object – Recommend Refusal. The proposed dwelling is strongly objected to by both the Parish Council and residents local to the site. The Parish Council consider that the proposed replacement dwelling would be visually intrusive and imposing and be detrimental to the rural character and amenities of the area as it is not in keeping with the character of the locality and does not have regard to the appearance, general design or massing of the original dwelling as required in policy DC16 of the NSLP, thus causing an unnecessary and unpleasant overdevelopment of the site.

The application is unacceptable as a replacement dwelling as it is 150% larger than the existing property, Brigadoon, and proposes a relocation to a separate part of the site as well as projecting a further 9m to the front and 6m to the back of the established building line of the lane.

The proposed new house is both out of character with the locality and its environment and out of scale with the existing development on the site. Moreover the roof design is of such a bulk as to suggest a future second floor potentially making the building up to 300% larger than the existing modest bungalow. It should also be noted that although described as a single storey dwelling, the roof height is actually higher than that of the neighbouring property, Elm Cottage, which is a two storey dwelling.

All existing properties in the lane, including Brigadoon, are positioned with the front of the property facing the road, however, the proposed dwelling has been located within the plot side-on and as such the south elevation that provides all daily living accommodation will face the neighbouring property, Elm Cottage, thus creating an unacceptable lack of privacy. Particularly given that the applicant has raised to the ground all landscaping.

The application forms advise that the dwelling will be attached to the mains sewer – but no such sewer exists as properties in this lane feed into septic tanks and it is understood from local residents that the existing tank to Brigadoon has difficulty coping with the modest bungalow let alone a proposed dwelling with many more drainage requirements.  Flooding is also an issue, specifically water run off from the site into the neighbouring property, Elm Cottage.

The Parish Council would also draw the officers attention to the fact that the current owners of the site have already removed all existing landscaping surrounding Brigadoon, but no landscaping scheme has been submitted with the application.  Furthermore, the Parish Council was interested to note the agent has described the design of the dwelling as in the style of Decimus Burton’s arts and crafts however no example of ‘bungalow’ design by Decimus Burton has been identified by any member of the planning committee nor is Decimus Burton local vernacular to this area.

Finally it is unfortunate that WDC did not notify all local residents affected by the proposed development as not all neighbours were fortunate enough to see the site notice and may have missed the opportunity to comment on the application.

On balance, the Parish Council therefore consider that the proposed dwelling is contrary to policies GD2, BE1 and DC16 of the Wealden NSLP and policies GD2, EN6 and DC18 of the Adopted Wealden Local Plan.

The Parish Council urge WDC to refuse this application, but if in any way they might be minded to approve this application, or if a further application is submitted in the future, it is requested that the size of the property is scaled down to be more in keeping with the existing property; it is located on the existing footprint and not rotated on the site; any privacy issues with neighbouring properties is mitigated against so as not to cause overlooking of any neighbours; the roof height is lowered; cross sections drawings are submitted showing the differentials in levels at the site and in relation to surrounding properties; and a full landscaping scheme is submitted.

5. Any other matters properly notified

None this meeting.

6. Announcements

None this meeting.

The meeting closed at 7.30p.m.

Signed:                                                                         Committee Chairman

Date:

Louise Daniel on January 6th, 2010

BUXTED PARISH COUNCIL

Clerk: Miss R Macklen

PO Box 202, Heathfield

East Sussex TN21 1BN

Phone/Fax: 01435 812757

Email: clerk@buxtedparish.org.uk

Website: www.buxtedparish.org.uk

5th January 2010

The Chairman and Members of the Planning Committee

The Chairman and Vice Chairman of the Council, copy: other Members of the Council

NOTICE OF MEETING

The Planning Applications below are to be considered by members of the Planning Committee on 12th January 2010 at 7.00p.m. in the Reading Room, Church Road, Buxted

At the discretion of the Chairman, members of the public may speak or ask questions immediately before the consideration of each planning application on the agenda.

1. Apologies for Absence

2. Declaration of Members personal and prejudicial Interests in respect of items on this agenda

3. The minutes of the Planning Committee held on 8th December 2009 be approved and signed as a correct record by the Chairman.
4 Planning Applications

4.1. Application No. WD/2009/2455/F

Location: The Millstones, Five Ash Down

Description: Side and rear extension to first floor bedrooms and single storey rear extension.  New single garage and store

Applicant: Mr S Butterfield

Agent: Mr J Butterfield

Sent: 15.12.09

4.2. Application No. WD/2009/2492/F

Location: Pinewood, Station Road, Buxted

Description: Demolition of redundant garage workshop and construction of one dwelling house.

Applicant: Ms R Miller

Agent: WAS Chartered Architects

Sent: 24.12.09

4.3. Application No. WD/2009/2627/F

Location: Subiaco, Ringles Cross, Uckfield

Description: Rooms in roof and raising of roof pitch

Applicant: Mrs J Crowhurst

Agent: Larkins & Pollington

Sent: 24.12.09

4.4. Application No. WD/2009/2651/F

Location: Ringles Cross Cottage, Ringles Cross, Uckfield

Description: Proposed change of use of existing retail storage & commercial accommodation to residential accommodation. Demolition of existing external store & erection of single storey entrance porch.

Applicant: Mr Hartfield

Agent: 3-D Architecture

Sent: 24.12.09

5. Any other matters properly notified

6. Announcements – a) Chairman of the Committee; b) Clerk to the Council

Beccy Macklen

Clerk to the Council

Copy to ESCC Cllr A G Reid, WDC Cllrs. N A D Buck & K Ogden